Hi. Yeah. It’s me. I guess I’m back. At least, I mean to be back. I’ve missed you. Does that count for something? Surely it must. (Though, dear ones, I’m on Twitter pretty much every day because it’s so much easier to find a few moments to talk to folks in 140-character bites while chasing after two kids. So if you’ve REALLY missed me you can always find me there.)
What’s finally gotten me off my ass to talk to you again? I wanted to say something on Twitter today and just couldn’t do it without spreading it out across ten tweets or more. At which point I realized that…Oh yeah. That’s what I used to use the blog for, right? To talk to people for more than 140 characters at a time? And I recalled that I liked it. I liked it quite a bit. And here I am. Are you still here?
What I wanted to talk about: process and the new novel. As you may recall from about three posts and three months ago, I had put the new novel (aka Novel Numbah Three, aka Cold Black Stars) on the back burner to finish revisions on The Revolution of Every Day and was finally able to pick it up again at the end of October. At that point it had been sitting for so long, and with only one thin little chapter to it, that the only way to pick it back up was to begin again. So at the end of October I did just that.
It took a year to write the first draft of my first novel, Drowning Practice (may it sleep comfortably in my former agent’s drawer. Yes, I said former agent. Yes, there’s a story behind that. Today is not the day for that story. Suffice it to say I still love her and she still loves me and we have parted on the most amicable of terms possible). I wrote that one while I was getting my MFA and the poor thing got workshopped nearly to death. In fact, I think it might not have been relegated to the drawer had it not been dragged through workshops before I even knew what it was really about and what it wanted to be. (Maybe someday I’ll pick it back up and try to find those shards worth keeping but it feels like something a stranger wrote, some thirty-year-old girl in Brooklyn with pink hair and no kids and a drafty old crumbling house.) I learned a lot about my revision process from writing that book, but perhaps not so much about my first-draft process, because of those workshops. I did, however, learn an invaluable lesson–one of the most important things I drew from that MFA experience: I never, ever, ever show a single word of anything to anyone when it’s in first draft. Maybe I’ll show second draft to my most trusted draft readers. Usually, though, I keep it to myself until third draft. It’s just too dangerous for me to have someone else’s ideas on a book or story before I truly understand where it’s going myself. I’m highly suggestible, I suppose. Because I was workshopping that novel as I wrote it, large parts of it got worked over and rewritten and reimagined several times before the book even had an end. I don’t recommend that, at least I don’t recommend it to myself anymore.
Everything was different with The Revolution of Every Day. I started it on the first day of a month-long residency at Ragdale in the fall of 2005 (oh the luxury of being a childless writer! I won’t see the inside of an artists’ colony for another ten years or so because I’m not the sort who likes to be away from her kids). I kept it to myself and worked steadily for that month and several months after, but by then I was working with my agent and there were more revisions to be done on Drowning Practice before it went out to publishers. I was pregnant with the kiddo and it was important to get the revisions nailed down before he was born because she and I both knew not much work would get done after his birth for a good long time. Revolution was set aside.
(By the way, if you can ever arrange to be pregnant at an artists’ colony, do so. Naps whenever you want them and someone else cooking your dinners.)
And then Kiddo was born. I didn’t write a word of fiction until he was about eighteen months old. Yes, that hurt. It hurt a lot. He’s worth it.
I have no idea how long it would have taken me to write that first draft of Revolution if Kiddo’s arrival hadn’t been a factor. It took six years to write eight drafts, but I don’t remember exactly when I finished that first draft. I know it was more than a year. And I know that I didn’t write it straight through from beginning to end. I did a lot of backtracking as I went. I reached the hundred-page point and went back and did a major rewrite of that whole first third. I did that a few more times as I worked my way toward the end. Only the final third fell out all in one piece, but that’s how the endings tend to come if you’ve taken the right path to get there.
Rachael and I talk craft a lot, and I find her process fascinating because it’s so different from what I’d done with the first two books and with my short fiction. She writes her first drafts incredibly quickly. She’s a firm believer in the Shitty First Draft. Now, I write a loose first draft, too, and I always write blind–I’m not an outliner by any means–but there’s always been that backtracking and tinkering. I’ve never started at the beginning and plowed straight on to the end, giving myself permission to write badly along the way, with the understanding that that’s what revisions are for.
Mind you, Rachael hates writing first drafts and loves to revise. I love first drafts and only tolerate revising because it’s necessary. I think she writes her first drafts that way because she’d rather get it over with as quickly as possible. But you know what? She gets results. She gets those first drafts done, and then digs in and gets her revisions done and has some damn fine books to show for it. (Especially one that hasn’t been published yet that is going to fucking blow you away when it comes out. No, it’s not a romance. Yes, it’s fiction. It’s… It’s amazing. Just you wait.)
With this third book, I decided I wanted to try something new. This was going to be the Do What Rachael Does novel. I decided I would write the first draft in three months. I would not backtrack. I would write fast and loose and let things fall where they fell and just trust that if I could just get it down I can fix and tweak and reshape in subsequent drafts. Because what the hell? I’m only thirty-eight. This is only my third novel. I’m too young and too new at this to be claiming a process set in stone–especially when the experiences of the first two books were determined by grad school and new motherhood.
I was dubious. I was afraid I was going to waste my time and spend all the juice of this story on a clumsy cluttered nonsensical mess of a draft that would be too far gone to revise into anything worth keeping. But I did it anyway. You know what? It’s been amazing. Working that fast all kinds of wonderful surprises are cropping up, all kinds of connections clicking into place as I go. It’s been so much easier to get out of my own way moving this quickly. I’m 70k words into the first draft, and it feels like its only got another 10 or 20k left in it. I’m aiming for a finished draft on my arbitrary deadline of February 20th, my half birthday. Yes, that will be a somewhat short manuscript, but I do seem to be consistent so far in writing very short first drafts and then expanding and layering in revisions.
And with this little girl getting older and more independent all the time, it won’t take me six years to get to a final draft on this book.
I’m hoping I’ll have a draft ready to send to readers by summer. We’ll see, though. It’s all new territory. But a first draft in three months! So fucking exciting.
Yeah! Fucking exciting! Yay for doing whatever the hell works.
Totally! I’ve got to admit I’m kind of shocked that it IS working so well. A little letting go is apparently good for me. Who knew?
I’ve missed these, Cari. Twats are not fulfilling; they rarely answer the questions they raise.
I have written often about the dangers inherent in workshopping. I have also written that if one is a good writer, he or she should never take the MFA process seriously; its purpose is to provide the requisite union card in case teaching becomes the best way for you to make a living. I wrote somewhere that handing your writing over to a workshop is tantamount to handing your pregnancy to a malevolent midwife.
Much good work has probably been drawered as a result of not taking this advice.
Send me the story of your agent.
Write my blog posts.
Donigan: I met some of my best draft readers in the MFA program and learned a hell of a lot about craft from some especially good professors and took several fantastic lit courses. I do wish I’d kept Drowning Practice out of workshop and just turned in stories, though.
You know the beginning of the agent story. I’ll email you (and Brad) with the middle and end in a bit.
I’ve had a similar experience between my first (making the rounds now!) and what’s currently my second novel. It took nearly a year for me to do a first draft of the first novel and I spent two and half more working it over. But for this next one, I’m in the plow-ahead camp as well. In a couple of months I’ve passed the 75K mark. So far, I’m finding this process much more manageble. I’m glad to hear that you’re moving along as well. Someday I hope to see one of these novels of yours.
Brad, I have every appendage crossed for your novel as it makes its way out there. Keep me posted!
so interesting to read about your process. and dude, so exciting too. of course I was distracted by the cute kid pictures 😉
Carrie: They are pretty damn cute, aren’t they?
YES!! This is how I write too and I love it. I have been known to plow through, write half, tinker on the first half for a day or two, and then plow through the second half, but yes, fast and furious is a lot of fun! I’m so glad you’re trying something new and exciting for this book. It’s been great seeing you update on twitter.
I have a really good feeling about this book. I’m looking forward to reading it!
Steph, no one–except maybe Joyce Carol Oates–churns out a draft as fast as you. It boggles the mind.
On so many levels I can relate. My novel that finally made it to the world (all by myself, I might add) began in workshop. I was lucky, though, that I started it nearly at the end of the MFA, because otherwise I too would’ve experienced many of the same issues you did with DP. I finally realized that I don’t want – or need – feedback until much, much later. For my ms., for my sanity. Otherwise I would write for workshop, the strong personalities I admired, not for myself and where I want the book to go. Workshops are great for craft; it’s almost best to separate the idea that anything coming out of it will make it to the world. Of course do NOT tell that to anyone in an MFA.
If you ever want to talk about the shift in publishing, you know where to find me. No matter what, I’m excited to hear more about this new draft. Happy 20K words to you!
Tina: No…I definitely would not have been willing to hear that while I was still in the program!
Glad you are back. I don’t tweet. Now or ever 🙂
…Okay, who is Donigan and why does he or she find twats unfulfilling? Is this one of those humorous autocorrect incidents, and it’s supposed to be Tweets that are unfulfilling? I’ll ponder this while I clean up the dinner dishes.
I’d love to hear more about your writing process, which is, to me, akin to the miracle of childbirth (hopefully with a BENEVOLENT midwife). Also, please tell more someday about the Artist’s Colony, which I instantly imagine as a paradisical cross between Shangri-La and The Bachelor TV show. Which I refuse to watch because it’s embarrassing, but I would totally watch it if the mansion was full of artists instead of lobotomized bimbos.
I’ve missed you; welcome back to the Blogosphere! 🙂
Glad to see you again on your blog! I’ve missed you. Damn, I need to set up a Twitter account.
Yay! Woke up this morning thinking of you, don’t know why, hoping that all was well with you and yours, reminding myself that you don’t “owe” your blog readers anything – and there you were!
I do the same thing with writing. Meaning I need to get out of my own way. I can work and rework the same three paragraph to death and then have nothing left for the rest of the story.
So glad you are enjoying this!